J. Paul Horne comments on receiving the GIC Global Citizen 2024 award

December 3, 2024

GIC College of Central Bankers Symposium – New York Athletic Club – Dec. 3, 2024

I am most honored, and more than a little surprised to receive the GIC’s esteemed Global Citizen award, especially when I see that list of very distinguished recipients over past years.

I suspect the GIC learned that during my 65 years of analyzing international economics and finance while living in Europe, I had the dubious pleasure of paying taxes in Italy, Malta, Belgium, France, the UK and, of course, the U.S. all the time. This made me very conscious of the fact that while American taxes are the lowest overall (as a % of GDP), our tax returns take the prize for being the most complicated. Having filled out so many international tax returns, I probably should have been a tax accountant. But I lacked the required sense of humor.

Linguistics may also have motivated the award. In my day-to-day work in French and Italian, I focused more on communicating than elegant speech. A Bank of France friend commented: “Paul, your French has the great virtue of.… making us concentrate.” Which I hope remains the case … no matter what language.

Speaking at the GIC’s Monetary and Trade Conferences since the early 1980s, I focused on the advantages of global interdependence: rapid growth of world trade, increased foreign direct investment, remarkable growth of financial markets, floating exchange rates and the collapse of Soviet communism.

Especially important from my viewpoint was the remarkable integration of Europe – from the modest European Coal and Steel Community to the impressive European Union of 27 countries and single Euro currency, a true miracle born of two world wars, both of which, we should remember, started in Europe.

Looking at the past 65 years, I see how easy it was to focus on the positive aspects of global interdependence for international investment managers and economists. But there were also crises, often triggered by “the smartest guys in the room” trying to circumvent sensible rules. My analysis of the “Enronitis” scandal won an award from the National Association for Business Economics. Unfortunately, my early warnings on the financial crisis of 2007-09 went unheeded.

The GIC’s focus on global interdependence since the U.S. bicentenary in 1976 was important to me and Smith Barney’s institutional investor and banking clients who had increasingly diversified internationally to boost overall returns and avoid domestic market volatility.

A key innovation boosting globalization of investment and economic growth was central bank independence and cooperation to ensure monetary stability and rapid response to financial crises and inflation. The GIC’s focus on central banks and monetary policy began in the 1980s and intensified with numerous international conferences which I was happy to participate in.

The GIC’s College of Central Bankers is a remarkable new institution whose Fellows represent an extraordinary collective knowledge of and experience in exercising monetary policy. The CCB will be, I’m convinced, invaluable as monetary policymakers today face extraordinary challenges following the financial crisis and Covid pandemic.

The past 15 years produced an alphabet soup of monetary innovation: ZIRP (zero interest rate policy), QE (quantitative easing), zero bound, R-star, SOFR (secured overnight financing rate), yield curve management and, most recently, QT (quantitative tightening). Dealing with the consequences of this extraordinary era of monetary innovation is proving difficult, especially as political leaders have allowed fiscal policy to go off the tracks in most developed countries.

The recent electoral victory by America Firsters and techno-libertarians means tariffs, trade protectionism, massive deregulation and dismantling of essential government institutions threaten U.S. equilibrium. And the rise of populist nationalism is evident in key European countries, notably France and Germany, the two pillars of European Union; and Japan.

I’m reminded of H. L. Mencken’s dim views of populist policies: For every complex problem, he said, there is an answer that is clear, simple, and … wrong.

Moreover, territorially ambitious dictators such as Xi and Putin, and the wannabes like Orban, actively challenge the rules-based global order that enabled the halcyon years of globalization after WW II. In particular, populist leaders detest independent monetary authorities. Our president-elect is notably irritated by the Fed’s independence. And late last month, the heads of the ECB, Bundesbank and Banque de France warned political leaders that European Union is threatened if capital markets are not unified to facilitate capital spending to improve productivity and economic growth.

Underlying economic trends make independent monetary policy even more essential: structural inflation exacerbated by global supply chain disruption; slowing productivity growth; excessive deficits and debt; and ageing populations. Accelerating climate change is rapidly aggravating all these challenges that confront central bankers responsible for financial stability.

I conclude by wishing the GIC and College of Central Banks very good luck in analyzing these new threats to global interdependence and proposing solutions. We need your expertise and dedication to protect global order and stability.

 

Scroll to Top